Key takeaway: Keep a policy-by-policy file that identifies the owner, insured, beneficiary, business purpose, pre-issue notice and consent, premiums, cash value, loans, changes and proceeds. Book accounting, premium deductibility and death-benefit exclusions require separate analysis.
This article is part of our guide to business recordkeeping, retention and controls.
A business may buy key-person life insurance to fund the disruption caused by an important employee’s death. The policy alone does not document the tax result. A later ownership change, employee departure or claim can expose gaps that were easy to overlook when premiums were paid automatically.

Identify the arrangement before assigning accounts
Record the exact legal owner, premium payer, insured person, beneficiary and anyone holding a collateral assignment. Explain whether the purpose is business continuity, a buyout, loan protection or an employee benefit. Compare the policy with the relevant company approvals, buy-sell agreement and lender documents.
An LLC is a legal form; an S corporation election concerns federal taxation. Neither label establishes who owns the insurance or guarantees its tax treatment. Confirm the actual tax classification separately. A policy owned by the company for its benefit differs from insurance owned personally or provided as compensation. Company payments for a personal policy may require wage, distribution, loan or other treatment based on the arrangement; do not automatically reclassify them as business insurance.
Separate ledger accounts and a policy register make transactions traceable. A dedicated bank account is not a general key-person insurance requirement. What matters here is identifying each payment and its purpose without confusing premiums, owner withdrawals and payroll.
Check employer-owned life insurance requirements before issuance
Section 101(j) generally addresses business-owned coverage on a person who is an employee when issued, where the business or a related person benefits directly or indirectly. Its employee definition also includes officers, directors and certain highly compensated employees. The rules generally apply to contracts issued after August 17, 2006, with transition rules for older contracts and exchanges. Review the actual arrangement against the statutory definitions and exceptions in section 101(j) and the Form 8925 instructions.
Before a covered policy is issued, obtain the required written notice and consent. The documents must address the employer’s intent to insure the employee, the maximum face amount, the employee’s agreement to coverage that may continue after employment ends, and the employer’s status as a beneficiary. The maximum must be stated in dollars or an appropriate salary multiple, not as an unspecified maximum. Keep dated evidence of delivery and consent. See the IRS notice and consent instructions.
A wholly owned corporation’s employee-owner is not exempt. For consent timing, issuance is the latest of application, coverage effectiveness and formal issuance. The contract must issue before the earlier of the consent’s one-year expiration or employment termination. Coverage increases and replacements need review; some material changes create a new contract. See Notice 2009-48, Q&A 4, 7, 9 and 14–16.
Missing consent is not an ordinary year-end cleanup item
Do not backdate a document. The IRS’s narrow inadvertent-failure relief requires a good-faith compliance effort, an inadvertent failure, and discovery and correction by the return due date for the policyholder’s year of issuance. Missing written consent cannot be cured after the insured dies. Have an adviser assess the actual facts under Notice 2009-48, Q&A 13.
Document the death-benefit exception separately
Valid notice and consent alone are insufficient. Section 101(j)(2) also requires a qualifying exception, such as employment during the 12 months before death, or director or specified highly compensated status at issuance. Another exception concerns proceeds paid to specified family members, beneficiaries, trusts or the estate, or used to buy an ownership interest from them. These categories have statutory definitions. Without a qualifying exception, section 101(j) generally limits the exclusion to premiums and other amounts paid, rather than automatically taxing every dollar. See section 101(j)(1)–(2).
For the ownership-purchase exception, the relevant amount must be paid or used by the due date, including extensions, of the policyholder’s return for the year the death benefit is treated as received. Preserve the purchase agreement and payment evidence. Notice 2009-48, Q&A 6 explains this timing.
Separate book entries from federal tax treatment
Section 264(a)(1) disallows premiums where the taxpayer is directly or indirectly a beneficiary. Recording a cost on the income statement does not make it deductible. Maintain the book-to-tax reconciliation and policy tax history instead of labeling every cash payment a deductible insurance expense.
Term coverage and prepayments
For accrual financial statements, ordinary term coverage without cash value generally produces insurance expense over the coverage period. An advance annual payment can initially create prepaid insurance. For example, a $2,400 payment for twelve months beginning October 1 would leave $1,800 prepaid and recognize $600 of expense at December 31, assuming even coverage and no other adjustments. Cash-basis or tax-basis statements require their own reporting analysis.
Permanent coverage and cash surrender value
Under the usual GAAP cash-surrender-value approach, the policy asset reflects the amount realizable under the contract at the reporting date, including applicable surrender charges. Do not substitute the death-benefit face amount or an illustrated future cash value. The interagency life insurance statement, Accounting Considerations, page 4 explains this measurement in its bank-policyholder context. Its banking investment restrictions are separate from this accounting point. Have the accountant apply ASC 325-30 to the company’s particular contract.
Reconcile the premium payment and the change in the policy asset together. As a simplified annual example, assume no loans, withdrawals, dividends paid out or other adjustments: beginning realizable cash value is $20,000, premiums paid are $6,000, and ending realizable cash value is $24,500.
| Account | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Life insurance asset | $4,500 | — |
| Insurance expense | $1,500 | — |
| Cash | — | $6,000 |
| Total | $6,000 | $6,000 |
The $6,000 cash outflow consists of a $4,500 increase in the recorded asset and $1,500 of net expense. The entry is an illustration, not a tax deduction calculation. Keep tax investment in the contract separately from book cash value. Obtain the carrier’s detailed history before recording policy loans, loan interest, dividends, withdrawals or surrender charges.
Maintain one complete file for each policy
| File section | Records to retain | Review trigger |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose and parties | Application, executed policy, riders, company approvals, owner and beneficiary designations | Purchase; ownership, employment or purpose change |
| Notice and consent | Dated notice, consent, delivery evidence, maximum coverage and issuance dates | Before issuance; additional coverage or replacement |
| Book and tax schedules | Invoices, payments, current carrier values, loan history, reconciliations and tax investment schedule | Each reporting period and material transaction |
| Related agreements | Buy-sell documents, collateral assignments, compensation arrangements and amendments | Signing, amendment, sale or employee departure |
| Annual reporting | Form 8925, employee counts, coverage totals, consent support and filed return | Annual return preparation |
| Claims and transfers | Claim submission, insurer determination, proceeds and interest breakdown, valuation and transfer/payment evidence | Before transfer or surrender; at death and settlement |
Applicable owners generally attach Form 8925 annually to their income tax return. The form reports employee and insured counts, coverage in force and consent information; filing it does not cure missing consent. Its instructions require retention while records remain material to tax administration. That can extend beyond the policy’s life. Keep superseded designations and transaction history with the current documents, and coordinate legal retention obligations and preservation holds. See Form 8925 and its instructions.
We break down Insurance Agencies separately in “Insurance Agencies: Commission Income and Producer Compensation Records.”
Review claims, surrender and transfers before posting
At death, separate the insurance benefit from interest and from amounts applied to loans or other obligations. Determine when a receivable and gain should be recognized under the financial-reporting framework; cash receipt is not automatically the recognition date. Remove the policy’s carrying amount when appropriate and avoid recognizing the full cash receipt as a gain while leaving the old policy asset on the books.
The tax analysis is independent. Interest on retained insurance proceeds is generally taxable even when the underlying death benefit qualifies for exclusion. Surrender can produce taxable income to the extent proceeds exceed the applicable cost. Request the carrier’s tax calculation and any information return, and reconcile them to the policy history. Review loans, outstanding balances, lapse and modified-endowment-contract status before a withdrawal or termination; cash received alone may not establish the tax result. See IRS Publication 525, Life Insurance Proceeds.
Before changing owners, document consideration, valuation, tax basis and any compensation or distribution element. A transfer for value can restrict the death-benefit exclusion; exceptions and reportable-policy-sale rules require fact-specific review under section 101(a)(2)–(3). Cash surrender value is not automatically the correct transfer valuation. Coordinate the carrier paperwork with the attorney and tax adviser before execution.
Arrange the year-end review
Send the accountant the policy register, current carrier statements, transaction reconciliations, consent file, prior reporting and proposed changes. Identify missing evidence explicitly. Ask for separate conclusions on book entries, tax adjustments, annual reporting and claim eligibility. Your attorney should review legal ownership and agreements, and the insurance professional should confirm contract terms and carrier requirements.
To discuss an accounting and tax review of your business records, contact CPA Firm South Florida and agree on the scope of the engagement.
Frequently asked questions
Are key-person life insurance premiums deductible?
Section 264(a)(1) disallows premiums when the taxpayer is a direct or indirect beneficiary. A book expense is a separate question from a tax deduction.
Does the sole shareholder need to sign the insurance consent?
Yes. A wholly owned corporation and its employee-owner are subject to the applicable written notice and consent requirements; personal knowledge does not replace the paperwork.
Does filing Form 8925 make the death benefit tax-free?
No. Reporting does not establish that the policy satisfies the notice, consent and qualifying-exception requirements, or resolve other restrictions on the exclusion.
Is cash surrender value the same as tax basis?
No. Maintain separate schedules for the financial-statement carrying amount and the tax investment in the contract, supported by the carrier’s transaction history.
How long should the policy file be kept?
Retain records while their contents remain material to tax administration, including after a policy ends if they support a transfer, claim or later return. Coordinate legal retention requirements and any preservation hold.
This article provides general recordkeeping information. Policy terms and the facts at issuance, transfer and claim determine the applicable accounting, tax and legal treatment.